Brother Consolmagno’s Hedging vs. Monsignor Balducci’s Certainty

Balducci in SiriusIt has come to our attention that Guy Consolmagno has protested the way he was presented in  Exo-Vaticana writing:

“There are no Vatican secrets about UFOs. Neither I nor anyone I know has any evidence that extraterrestrials exist. We do not believe that ‘Jesus is a hybrid’ or any of the other bizarre claims that this author makes. He is either seriously deluded, or a deliberate con-man.”

While this is not too surprising in light of thew worldview analysis in Exo-Vaticana, it is a deflection. While Consolmagno has certainly implied in print that Jesus came “not only as the Son of Man but also as a Child of other races”[1] he has publicly suggested bizarre acts like baptizing an ET, “no matter how many tentacles it has,”[2] However, the thesis of our book does not rest on one man but a preponderance of the evidence. It was Pope John Paul II’s close friend Monsignor Corrado Balducci that went on Italian television announcing that in light of the UFO phenomenon, the existence of ETs is a certainty. Interestingly the new documentary Sirius features Balducci saying they are superior to us as well. The Catholic Church has never disassociated itself from the below statement.Luckily this was recorded so the blanket denials and obfuscation tactics will not stand up to scrutiny.

So which story is it Vatican: “there is no evidence” or “it’s a certainty”?



[1] Guy Consolmagno, Intelligent Life in the Universe: Catholic Belief and the Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligent Life (London: Catholic Truth Society, 2005), 37.

[2] “Pope’s astronomer says he would baptise an alien if it asked him,”

About Cris Putnam
Logos Apologia is the ministry of Cris D. Putnam. The mission of Logos Apologia is to show that logic, science, history and faith are complementary, not contradictory and to bring that life-changing truth to everybody who wants to know.


  1. shannon says:

    a straight answer would be nice. he gave one without saying exactly what he was saying exists between man and angels but did say something does.

  2. owl says:

    One thing is certain, they are both made to look like fools. I got a feeling that the occult orchestra behind the scenes is struggling to deliver the goodies and meet deadlines to get their show started. Thus comet ISON will probably turn into a non-event like elenin.

    • hopeful_watcher says:

      Owl, I too believe that the occultists thought the “show” would have already been underway. I think they were actually shooting for the 2012 Mayan thing and got knocked back on their heels when nothing happened. I believe there is something to this three days of darkness agenda, but we’ll have to wait and see on that one. That might have been one of the “goodies” they couldn’t deliver on, because that so-called prophecy is in catholic theology.

      • owl says:

        Yep, I think the 2012 maya was one of their original target timeframes but i noticed back in the second half of 2011 that lot of their plans they were building up on were getting derailed.

        Luciferians are so deluded they are making mistakes left and right and are getting even more exposed in the process. Attempts at mocking God’s plan and forcing their timeline will always send them scrambling to their underground holes like the cockroaches they are. Its comical to observe but still dangerously serious at the same time.

  3. Maria Tatham says:

    Another thing that is certain is that those who deny the truth will believe anything. Blind, they are led further astray. May God pity many and call them out of darkness!